Human Genetic Engineering is Morally Justified Essay

Affirmative—Human Genetic Engineering is Morally Justified When they are finally attempted†¦genetic manipulations will†¦be done to change a death sentence into a life verdict. In agreeing with this quote by James D. Watson, director of the Human Genome Project, I affirm today’s resolution, Human genetic engineering is morally justified. I will now present a few definitions. Human genetic engineering is the altering, removal, or addition of genes through genetic processes. Moral is pertaining to right conduct; ethical. Justified is to be proper; well-deserved. Therefore, something that is morally justified is ethically beneficial. My value today will be cost-benefit justice. When we examine the benefits that human genetic†¦show more content†¦If we negate the resolution today, we stop this research, we stop the chance to cure cancer through genetic engineering, and most importantly, we stop any ability to cure any disease when we are moving towards such a goal. CONTENTION 2: Human genetic engineering can help prolong life. An example should prove my point. Thanks to genetic engineering, in the future we will be able to clone organs to help people live longer. A person with one kidney could very well clone that kidney through genetic engineering, and end up with two kidneys. This would remove the long waiting lists and the needs for organ donors. People would no longer be turned away because science couldn’t help them. Genetic engineering would provide organ cloning as a possibility to prevent disease and improve the health of society, when without it, no such possibility could even exist. People would undoubtedly die because genetic engineering wasn’t there to provide that extra kidney, or that replacement heart. But if we affirm the resolution, say that genetic engineering is morally justified, we can cure disease and we can prolong life, and thus the health of society is improved. Such a benefit cannot be ignored, and thus m y value of cost-benefit justice is provided for by affirming the resolution. CONTENTION 3: The possibleShow MoreRelatedGenetic Engineering Is Ethically Justified824 Words   |  4 PagesAS Level Ethics Genetic engineering Example of part (b) question (b) â€Å"Genetic engineering is ethically justified.† Discuss [10] Since the development of genetic engineering in the 1970s, scholars have questioned its ethical justification, claiming that it was playing God’ and was unnatural. Others claimed that humans have always altered their environment to benefit themselves. An example is that of genetically modified crops which some people believe can be justified for a number ofRead MoreGenetic Engineering : Medical Perfection Or Playing God1280 Words   |  6 PagesThesis Statement â€Å"Genetic engineering differs from cloning in key ways. Whereas cloning produces genetically exact copies of organisms, genetic engineering refers to processes in which scientists manipulate genes to create purposefully different versions of organisms—and, in some cases, entirely new living things†, duplication of genetic cells is known as human cloning. Development of genetic engineering biotechnologies undermines the natural autonomy of life. Does genetic engineering interfere withRead MoreJohn Stuart Mill And Utilitarianism1202 Words   |  5 Pages Furthermore, Despite Walter Glannon’s second argument against genetic enhancement for personal gain, I contend that the philosophy of John Stuart Mill and Utilitarianism can be used to show that society should will that genetic enhancement be morally acceptable if the adverse cognitive or emotional effects are outweighed by the benefits. Glannon argues that gene enhancement is morally objectionable because â€Å"there would be the unacceptable social cost of some people suffering from adverse cognitiveRead MoreThe Effects Of Cloning On The World Today? Should Scientists Advance Further Through Experimentation Of Human Cloning?940 Words   |  4 Pagesexperimentation of human cloning? Cloning is a generic term that describes the fabrication of a biological material with the same genetic makeup as that of the original or copied material. Mammalian cloning has its benefits, such as the eradication of defective genes (gene cloning), the use of cloning as an alternative infert ility treatment (reproductive cloning), and the provision of a companion of sorts (therapeutic cloning). However, recent statistics show that sixty percent proclaim it is morally wrong toRead MoreHumans, Animals, And Nature2341 Words   |  10 PagesPY 4647: Humans, Animals, and Nature (Ben Sachs) Thom Almeida (110003776) Word count: 2,216 Introduction Modern technological advances in animal farming coupled with a greater desire for food production have led to increased suffering of animals to suit our own interests. Bernard Rollin has argued that unless this trend is discontinued, which he deems unlikely to happen, genetic engineering of animals is a morally preferable option compared to not intervening at all in order to ameliorate the frustrationRead More Genetic Engineering: The Solution to Hunger and Disease Essay1593 Words   |  7 PagesGenetic Engineering: The Solution to Hunger and Disease   Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚   In case you were not sure, we don’t live in a perfect world. Millions of people die every year. Two significant causes of death are hunger and disease (I am aware that there are more causes such as war and crime, but they are irrelevant to this essay). There are about 5.6 billion people on earth; all of whom need to eat. However, only a certain amount of food (less that what everyone needs) can be produced. With the use ofRead MoreSavior Siblings1071 Words   |  5 Pagespre-implantation genetic testing moral? Can parents make the decisions for their kids about organ donation? In order for this ethical dilemma to be resolved these questions need to be answered. In the case of Molly Nash, the family was not morally culpable for their decision to have another child to save Molly’s life because Adam was not born solely to save his sister’s life and because the methods used to save Mollys life had no adverse effects on Adam. Using preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD)Read MoreShould New Zealand Allow Genetically Modified Food? Essay1570 Words   |  7 Pagesof molecular genetics. New ways are discovered and implemented to improve what nature has to offer, a variety of species are being genetically modified in order to produce new substances and carry out different functional roles (Ministry for the Environment, 2004). With the use of genetic engineering a gene of interest is introduced into a different species, allowing for a desired trait to be acquired in that species (Hui Culbertson, 2006). With the introduction of genetic engineering it is now possibleRead MoreThe Invention Of The 21st Century2497 Words   |  10 Pageshave not just been a break from the normalcy, but a sudden leap forward in revealing the dark secrets of biological life and bringing them into the light of human knowledge (Fletcher 8). The act of genetic manipulation or engineering may be akin to the Greek myth of Prometheus. He stole fire from the heavens in a compassionate act to ease human suffering. While this fire may have been frightening at first, when man learned to harness it he was able to make vastly improve the quality of life. PreservingRead MoreThe Invention Of Designer Babies1257 Words   |  6 PagesIntroduction Throughout the world, the potential to genetically modify embryos has created controversy whether this procedure if ‘morally correct.’ ‘Designer babies’ have been created by screening embryos for genetic diseases. However, ‘Designer babies’ has also been used to contain selected desired qualities such as eye colour, hair colour and skin complexion. The question remains, â€Å"where is the line drawn for ‘designer babies?’† In Vitro Fertilisation â€Å"In Vitro Fertilisation (IVF) is a procedure